(Web Desk) – Chief Justice of Pakistan Yahya Afridi has reportedly rejected an informal request to convene a Judicial Commission meeting regarding the transfer of judges of the Islamabad High Court, according to official correspondence cited in legal sources.
In a written response to the Chief Justice of the Islamabad High Court, the Chief Justice of Pakistan stated that a commission meeting cannot be convened for judge transfers without a justified institutional reason, adding that such action could be interpreted as punitive in nature.
The letter further emphasized that transferring judges without clear legal grounds may undermine judicial independence and constitutional balance. It warned that administrative transfers should not be treated as routine executive actions, as this could set a “dangerous precedent” for the judiciary.
The response also noted concerns over representation and structural balance within the Islamabad High Court, stating that transfers could affect provincial representation and disrupt the framework of the Islamabad High Court Act 2010.
Chief Justice Afridi reportedly highlighted that the Constitution provides a clear mechanism under Article 209 for proceedings involving judges, and any action outside this framework could risk violating constitutional principles.
The letter also referenced procedural rules of the Judicial Commission, noting that while certain members may request meetings under Article 175A procedures, the purpose and justification for such meetings must be clearly communicated to all members.
Legal observers say the development underscores ongoing sensitivities around judicial independence, administrative authority, and institutional balance within Pakistan’s judicial system.
